The truth about how Spain is changing

Catalonia court rejects new coronavirus lockdown

Jul 13, 2020, 8:26 am

Thread: Public prosecutor last night argued against lockdown becuase it must be ordered by national government.

1. Duty court in Lérida HAS REJECTED the new coronavirus lockdown ordered by Torra's regional government in Catalonia. Let's take a look at the ruling.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 8:27 am | On Twitter

2. Ratification of the regional goverment's order “for the containment of the epidemic outbreak of the COVID-19 pandemic" in the towns of Lérida, Alcarrás, La Granja d'Escarp, Massalcoreig, Serós, Soses, Torres de Segre, Sucs and Raimat was sought last night at the duty court.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 8:37 am | On Twitter

3. Catalan government wrote in the new order that “despite the measures taken” the previous week, with the initial order, which was ratified, “the epidemiological situation [...] continues to show an increase the number of daily infections”.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 8:42 am | On Twitter

4. The new lockdown, in theory, came into effect last night at midnight. What is Torra going to do now? Will Sánchez have to act? What situation have the citizens of Lérida and the surrounding area been left in? Can they go about their normal lives or are they locked down?

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 8:48 am | On Twitter

5. Civil Protection in Catalonia, for example, has just tweeted out instructions for the new lockdown in Lérida as if the order from the duty court did not exist.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 8:51 am | On Twitter

6. The measures in the new lockdown order, announced by the regional government in Catalonia yesterday, included, among others, the restriction of personal movements (everyone go home) and the restriction of social contacts (“people you normally live with”).

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 8:58 am | On Twitter

7. It also included an order for companies to only offer service without physical contact with customers.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:02 am | On Twitter

8. The judge starts with the State of Alarm, Exception and Siege Act of 1981: the national government may declare the state of alarm, says Article 4, and the First Minister of a Spanish region may if he needs to request the government do so, according to Article 5.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:10 am | On Twitter

9. Judge also cites Article 54 of the 2011 General Public Health Act: authorities, including regional authorities, “may take all necessary measures to ensure compliance with the law” if there is an exceptional, grave or urgent situation.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:15 am | On Twitter

10. Such measures require, in theory, “after hearing the persons concerned” and the judge highlights in bold the phrase “the measures taken must, in any event, respect the principle of proportionality”.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:17 am | On Twitter

11. Judge then spends several pages quoting several relevant laws, including the Public Health Act 2009, and stresses again in bold that “the measure must be proportional to the aims pursued and the situation that motivates it”.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:25 am | On Twitter

12. The judge argues that “according to the figures supplied” by the regional government, the ordered lockdown measure is “not proportional”. What figures? How is the coronavirus pandemic really going in Lérida and the Lower Segre area?

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:29 am | On Twitter

13. Friday's Health Ministry pdf says there is a cumulative incidence rate across Catalonia of 19.58 cases per 100,000 inhabitants over 7 days. The judge notes that the equivalent rate in the specific case of Segrià has risen from 149 last week to...187.8.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:34 am | On Twitter

14. The judge says that the Catalan government has introduced a new sub-block of data for the Lower Segre area, “pointing out that the incidence rate is 216.3 per 100,000 inhabitants” but that they have not provided prior data to compare the evolution. Again, data matters.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:37 am | On Twitter

15. The information provided by the Catalan govt on outbreaks is not accurate, says the judge. They mix companies and towns. They do not specify towns. If they have the outbreaks under control and identified, what need is there to order a general lockdown?

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:41 am | On Twitter

16. Catalan govenrment has not provided data illustrating “the existence of a grave and very large community transmission of the virus”, says the judge, which would justify the “very serious restriction and limitation of rights”. “They don't give us any more information"

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:45 am | On Twitter

17. Catalan government has not done enough homework to order a total lockdown in the Lower Segre area, says the judge. The measures “not only are not proportional but are based on generic data and expressions”. They could order individual home confinement.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:50 am | On Twitter

18. Now, “the high capacity for expansion [of coronavirus] is public and notorious,” says the judge, but the Catalan government wants to lock everyone up at home, except to go to work.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:53 am | On Twitter

19. What the Catalan government is proposing in the Lower Segre area is not “a simple limitation of movements”, which could be done with the 1986 Act, but rather “seriously affects” rights protected by the Spanish Constitution itself.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 9:59 am | On Twitter

20. Hence the need for a state of alarm in March, argues the judge, with 15-day extensions and monitored by parliament.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 10:01 am | On Twitter

21. Catalan govt has copied and pasted March state of alarm decree, says the judge, but without setting any time limitation, so even more serious, and Torra seeks to “circumvent the application of the partial state of alarm” provided for by the 1981 Act which protects rights.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 10:04 am | On Twitter

22. Judge concludes, as prosecutor did last night, that “this is a state responsibility and is exercised, moreover, with the guarantee of the intervention of parliament”. The path, she points out to Torra, is to ask the government to declare another state of alarm.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 10:07 am | On Twitter

23. This ruling creates problems for: i) the immediate plan to try to control coronavirus, ii) the always ongoing separatist-Spanish state debate, iii) Sanchez's general plan to leave the management of the pandemic to the regions throughout Spain.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 10:10 am | On Twitter

24. Having followed the issue of coronavirus data since February so closely, the judge raises a fascinating point. If Catalan govt had done its homework better, would data have shown that there is imminent, real danger or that it does not exist and this is an overreaction?

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 10:20 am | On Twitter

25. In essence, the judge has asked the Catalan government for two things: more data and precision about the reality of the situation in Lérida and the Lower Segre area, and more proportionality and correct action in the measures to be taken, according to the law.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 10:30 am | On Twitter

26. And how now will Sánchez, Illa and Fernando Simón react to the judge's ruling in Lérida? What will they do next? He is still the Prime Minister of the whole country.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 10:45 am | On Twitter

27. Torra announces that his Catalan government will pass a regional decree “in the next few hours” that will allow them, according to him, to continue with the new lockdown in the Lower Segre area. That wasn't among the options the judge mentioned in her ruling.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 11:26 am | On Twitter

28. “No one should play politics or fight about turf with healthcare” says Aragonés (Deputy FM), after announcing with Torra that instead of asking for a new state of alarm or providing more precise information, they will try to pass express regional decree to achieve their goal.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 11:30 am | On Twitter

29. Torra is asked what citizens in the Lower Segre area should do this morning. “Follow the recommendations of the Catalan government”, he replies, “without any doubt”. Follow Torra, not the law, says Torra.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 11:36 am | On Twitter

31. Regional high court in Catalonia confirms that the judge not signing off on the new lockdown order means that it currently has no effect. It is not applicable to the citizens of Lérida and nearby towns at this time. They are free.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 12:00 pm | On Twitter

30. Will a a regional decree (Torra's answer) ever be able to win against the Constitution and the 1981 State of Alarm Act (the judge's argument)? Is it wasting time while coronavirus spreads? If we go down that path, do we end up in Spain with 17 regional coronavirus laws?

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 12:07 pm | On Twitter

32. Chief Public Prosecutor in Lérida, Juan F Bone, tells me regarding Torra's new lockdown plan that: “There cannot be a decree if it touches on fundamental rights. The regulation would again be illegal and could be challenged before the Constitutional Court”.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 2:13 pm | On Twitter

33. Catalonia has announced a new total of 76,619 cases, an increase of 301 compared to yesterday's figure.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 5:19 pm | On Twitter

34. Torra is perplexed or annoyed with the public prosecutor in Lérida for rejecting out of hand his new plan for a regional Catalan decree to lock citizens down: “But what on earth is this?”.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 5:27 pm | On Twitter

35. Mayor of Barcelona, Colau, has said they have registered 458 Covid cases in that city in one week, with 24 “small” but “fully controlled” outbreaks: “we have almost tripled new infections” in seven days.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 5:43 pm | On Twitter

36. If we compare today's totals (for yesterday) and those of the 7th (for July 6), the most affected areas of Catalonia are: Barcelona city, Metropolitan South (Hospitalet) and Lérida.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 6:08 pm | On Twitter

37. Illa says at the press conference that citizens in and around Lleida should follow the advice of the health authorities of the Catalan government. Is nobody going to listen to the judge?

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 6:17 pm | On Twitter

38. Health Ministry says that “the day before” (so, yesterday), there were 164 new coronavirus cases, but between today's total and Friday's total they have bunge in... 2,045 more cases.

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 6:34 pm | On Twitter

39. 7- and 14-day case totals have rocketed up in Health Ministry figures since Friday: - 7-day total: +989 cases - 14-day total: +1,139 - total cases: +2,045 - symptoms 7 days: +153 - symptoms 14 days: +352

Published: Jul 13, 2020, 6:40 pm | On Twitter

40. Analysis: Catalonia, the law and coronavirus lockdowns. What is Torra doing? https://www.thespainreport.es/articles/612-200714115603-catalonia-the-law-and-coronavirus-lockdowns

Published: Jul 14, 2020, 12:09 pm | On Twitter

Guarantee independent journalism

Your support guarantees the future of independent journalism. Every reader counts and it all adds up, whether you choose $5 or $10 or $25 each month. You invest directly in better reporting and more detailed analysis—in English and in Spanish—of the most important stories affecting Spain. The truth about how Spain is changing.

Iberian Adventurer

More text: audio scripts
Patrons Only: column
Patrons Only: audio
More audio: questions
More images: high-res
Patrons Only: videos
20x30cm trip prints
We must witness Spain

Spain News Fan

More text: audio scripts
Patrons Only: column
Patrons Only: audio
More audio: questions
More images: high-res
Patrons Only: videos
All the news & analysis

Supporter Of The Truth

More text: audio scripts
Patrons Only: column
Patrons Only: audio
Support the truth

Your : €/month
Which country do you pay taxes in?

How does it work?

Click on the you wish to
Make sure your tax country is correct
Enter your email address and credit card details
The server will check your card and do some sums…
Click "Support independent journalism now"
That's it, welcome aboard, you will get a couple of emails

Notes:

If you would like to a larger , please click here
You can print receipts or invoices for all your in "My Account"
Any problems or questions, email: matthew@thespainreport.es

Get The Spain Report by email

Get original, detailed, independent reporting and analysis of the stories changing Spain. Full-text articles delivered right to your inbox, in English. You can also choose to get them in Spanish. No ads, no spam. Just readers.

What is The Spain Report?

Independent reporting and analysis of the most important stories changing the country, written by Matthew Bennett, a British journalist who has been living and working in Spain for most of the past 20 years. Read more

Questions, stories, interviews, tips: matthew@thespainreport.com
WhatsApp/Signal: (0034) 647 81 81 43
Twitter: @matthewbennett